CFRP Policy Brief | B.035.0518
The state of Texas recognizes the important role that fathers play in the lives of their children and families. Involved fatherhood is linked to better outcomes on nearly every measure of child wellbeing from cognitive and emotional developmenta and academic successb, to reduced delinquencyc,d, and improved mental healthe. In addition to fathers’ direct involvement with their children, fathers’ provision of financial resources, either formally or informally, reduces material hardship for families and mitigates the negative impacts of poverty on child wellbeing and outcomesf. Texas also understands that fathers’ needs are distinct from those of mothers and other family members. Father-specific supports in Texas feature an array of services, including state-funded programs and local initiatives designed to increase fathers’ economic self-sufficiency and improve their parenting knowledge and skills. Although Texas has taken important steps to support fathers, which are described below, the state can do still more to support fathers, and contribute to improving the wellbeing of children.
State-level father supports
Providing support for individuals before they become parents can help set the stage for a successful transition to parenthood. Texas’s Parenting and Paternity Awareness (p.a.p.a.) curriculum, offered in public middle and high schools including those in Texas Juvenile Justice Department (TJJD) state-operated facilities,g provides information to students on the rights, responsibilities, and realities of parenting.h The Texas Department of State Health Services (DSHS) provides information for expectant fathers on its Healthy Texas Babies website,i and HHSC WIC’s Peer Dad program, funded by DSHS’ Maternal and Child Health through Title V, features mentorship, parenting and breastfeeding education, and additional resources for expectant and new fathers.j
Child custody and visitation
For unmarried or divorced parents, Texas law presumes joint managing conservatorship,m meaning that both parents have legal rights and responsibilities, though not necessarily equal possession of the child.n In recognition of the importance of parental involvement, Texas requires child support orders to be accompanied by a parenting time plan to ensure access and visitation,o and requires that visitation court orders be obeyed, regardless of whether the noncustodial parent (NCP) is paying child support.p Texas was the first state to require that a child support order be accompanied by a parenting plan.q The Office of the Attorney General (OAG) Child Support Division also dedicates resources to assist NCPs in establishing and enforcing access and visitation, including a phone hotline and online resource directory.f
Texas requires noncustodial parents to provide financially for their children. However, the state is also aware that parents may face challenges and circumstances that make it difficult to meet their obligations. NCPs can request a child support order modification due to a material and substantial change in circumstances through the Child Support Review Process or a court hearing.s To help NCPs meet their obligations, in partnership with the Texas Workforce Commission (TWC), the Child Support Division pioneered the NCP Choices program, including employment services and enhanced child support compliance monitoring services for low-income, unemployed or underemployed NCPs.t The OAG also provides resources and information about child support to incarcerated, recently released, and paroled parents.u
Support throughout the child's life
Texas has several programs and services in place to support fathers and their families. The Department of Family and Protective Services (DFPS) Prevention and Early Intervention Division (PEI) offers one of the only father-specific programs offered at the state level, the Fatherhood EFFECT program. In addition, DFPS PEI’s Military Families and Veteran Pilot Prevention Program, Help through Intervention and Prevention (HIP), Healthy Outcomes through Prevention and Supports (HOPES), Home-Visiting Education and Leadership (HEAL), Safe Babies, and Texas Home Visiting (THV) provide parenting education and support to parents, including fathers, to increase families’ protective factors, and improve children’s wellbeing.v DFPS’ Child Protective Services (CPS) division put in place a Responsible Fathering initiative to increase outreach and provide information and support to fathers of children in the child welfare system.w The Texas Workforce Commission (TWC) helps parents locate high-quality, accessible childcare,x and the Texas Education Agency (TEA) provides support and guidance to parents whose children are in pre-K through Family Engagement Plans in each district and the Start Smart Texas initiative.y The Texas Department of Criminal Justice (TDCJ) partners with local volunteer organizations to offer parenting programs in its facilities,z and offers a resource center for incarcerated parents and their families called GO KIDS.aa,bb Texas A&M AgriLife Extension Service, a statewide educational agency that partners with the nationwide Cooperative Extension System of the National Institute of Food and Agriculture and Texas county governments, developed the Fathers Reading Every Day (FRED) program to encourage fathers and father figures to read to their children daily.cc
As part of the state’s larger efforts to support fathers, build knowledge, and raise awareness of the state of fatherhood programs in Texas, DFPS PEI and the Child and Family Research Partnership (CFRP) have co-hosted annual Texas Fatherhood Summits since 2016.2 The summits brought together hundreds of service providers, researchers, advocates, and representatives from government and state agencies, and community nonprofits.dd Since January 2016, CFRP and PEI have convened the Texas Fatherhood Interagency Council (TFIC) on a quarterly basis. The TFIC seeks to raise awareness of fathers’ roles and impacts on family wellbeing, identify ways to better support fathers, and build connections and capacity for cross-agency collaboration. Currently, the TFIC is composed of fatherhood stakeholders in seven Texas state agencies: DFPS, DSHS, OAG, TEA, TJJD, TWC, and the Health and Human Services Commission (HHSC).
Local-level father supports
More than 70 programs exist across Texas to provide fathers with the tools they need to be effective and involved parents. Although funding information is not available for all of the programs, the majority appear to be funded by state or federal sources, or a combination of them. These programs are operated by nonprofits and other local organizations at the local level, serving just one city or county, with only a handful operating in multiple counties.ee Many programs are directed toward fathers and mothers, and offer general parenting skills education or resources. Other programs are aimed toward specific parent populations, including teens, parents in the child welfare system, noncustodial parents, members of the armed forces or veterans, and incarcerated parents, in which fathers are often overrepresented.ff
Gaps in services to fathers
No official state-level body exists to promote comprehensive policies and services for fathers
Acknowledging the gap in comprehensive services and programming for fathers, some states have developed broad state-led initiatives to support fathers and address some of the systemic challenges they face. Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Ohio, and Virginia have created state fatherhood commissions to raise awareness about the importance of father involvement, advise state agencies on best practices for providing and coordinating services for fathers, and review policy and legislation to assess the impact on fathers and families.jj,kk In particular, Connecticut, Ohio, and Virginia help build capacity at the local level by supporting local responsible fatherhood programs through funding or training.ll,mm
In the late 1990s and early 2000s, Texas was on the forefront of promoting father involvement. At the Texas Fatherhood Forum: A Statewide Call to Action in 1998, then-Governor Bush announced the creation of the Texas Fatherhood Initiative (TFI), which consisted of a statewide public awareness campaign and the creation of an organization to provide referrals, educational materials, and technical assistance to community-based fatherhood programs across the state.nn,oo In addition to publishing a report on the state of fatherhood in Texas,pp the TFI also provided seed grants for local fatherhood programs.qq The TFI did not last beyond Governor Perry’s administration.
Agencies need greater coordination of efforts to support fathers
As mentioned previously, CFRP and PEI convene stakeholders from multiple Texas agencies on a quarterly basis to share the work they are doing to support fathers and their families and identify opportunities for collaboration. Despite the value of this gathering, Texas state agencies need further support to coordinate their work with one another. For example, multiple agencies have platforms to share information with parents, including HHSC’s Healthy Texas Baby Initiative,rr TEA’s Start Smart Texas,ss and DFPS’ Help and Hope campaign.tt However, agencies could do more to link to one another’s resources or go further to create a no-wrong-door portal where parents can access information about all the state agencies and available resources at one location. Similarly, agencies can do more to collaborate at the planning stages and create policies and programs that are informed by and use the services and policies of other state agencies.
Fathers are not accurately identified and counted to ensure their needs are met
Most states, including Texas, lack a way to accurately count and identify fathers. Collecting accurate data on fathers has proven challenging: large-scale surveys, the census, and research studies do not use consistent measures,uu and mothers are often used as proxy respondents to provide data about fathers, which can result in biased information.vv Without information on all fathers—both custodial and noncustodial, residential and nonresidential—Texas lacks important context on families and their needs.
Noncustodial parents need options for managing child support arrears
Many NCPs enter the child support system already in debt due to retroactive child support orders, and are subsequently unable to meet their current obligations and settle their debts due to their low incomes.ww Research indicates that child support enforcement and collection, however, can be supported through the use of debt compromise or forgiveness programs.xx Child support offices in California, Kansas, Maryland, and Minnesota have partnered with local fatherhood programs to provide debt relief, and assistance in regaining licenses, in exchange for an NCP’s participation in responsible fatherhood programming and contributions to a current child support order or debts.yy
Social services and programs focus mostly on mothers and children, not fathers
Texas state agencies strive to offer a whole-family approach in their policies and programs, but fathers are often left out. When program names such as Women, Infant, and Children Supplemental Nutrition Program or the Maternal and Child Health program do not mention fathers, it is not surprising that some fathers may struggle to see their role and value in the lives of their young children.zz Moreover, because mothers are often perceived as the primary caregiver, even in two-parent families, many fathers do not understand that they are welcome or expected to participate in programs and policies that are directed at parents, such as Texas Home Visiting or parenting education programs, unless they are explicitly invited as fathers.aaa
Programs meet some, but not all of Texas fathers' needs
Currently, efforts to serve Texas fathers through fatherhood programs are disjointed in terms of the populations they serve, the rigor of their evidence base, and the services they offer, including employment assistance or parenting skills. About two-thirds of the programs we identified are located in Austin, Dallas, El Paso, Fort Worth, Houston, or San Antonio.bbb As a result, fathers may access programs that only meet some of their needs, if they can access a program at all. Moreover, although previous research on fatherhood programs indicates that men strongly value a “fathers-only” approach, only about one-third of the programs we identified are directed specifically to fathers.ccc
Local programs are disconnected from one another
Although many programs target similar populations of fathers and may even operate in the same communities, programs often work in isolation from one another and from larger systemic efforts to provide services or promote awareness about responsible fatherhood. Many of the program providers express a desire for more opportunities to meet one another to share lessons learned and best practices. State-level fatherhood commissions or practitioner networks play a valuable role in connecting program providers and practitioners to facilitate communication and learning.ddd
Texas should continue working to establish a formal state-level council to support fatherhood with a clear, measureable statement of purpose, and resources to support its agenda. In addition to providing guidance to the state on policies and laws that impact fathers and families, the council can provide and share resources for policymakers and fatherhood providers on research and best practices, and share a publicly accessible clearinghouse that would allow organizations to share information about the programs they offer and provide updates on their programs as necessary. This inventory would also allow fathers to more easily identify the resources available in their area. The council could also facilitate state and regional networks for fatherhood stakeholders, to facilitate support and information sharing.